When someone is arrested for grand larceny, the first fear is prison. The second is money. The law cares about both: punishment and making victims whole. A seasoned grand larceny attorney thinks in two tracks from day one, identifying diversion or treatment-based resolutions that can keep a client out of a felony conviction, and structuring restitution in a way that satisfies the prosecutor, the court, and the victim without financially ruining the client. Those two tracks often overlap. A well-crafted restitution plan can unlock a diversion program. A successful diversion can narrow the restitution figure to something manageable. The key is timing and credibility.
Grand larceny covers a range of conduct, from shoplifting expensive electronics to siphoning funds in a workplace. Charging thresholds differ by state, typically defined by the value of the property. In many jurisdictions, grand larceny starts around $1,000 to $2,500 in value and climbs from there, with higher degrees for larger sums and aggravating factors. Prosecutors look at more than the sticker price. They assess intent, planning, prior history, whether the property was recovered, whether there is a paper trail suggesting fraud, and whether the case has broader public interest. All of this informs whether a diversion program is even on the table.
What prosecutors look for before offering an off-ramp
I have sat across from prosecutors who were ready to hammer a first-time defendant over a $5,000 theft because the victim was furious and felt betrayed, and I have seen them agree to a non-criminal disposition on a $40,000 embezzlement when the defendant paid back funds quickly and showed a documented mental health crisis. The facts matter. So does the posture of the case when it arrives on a desk.
Prosecutors tend to ask the same quiet questions. Can we get the victim made whole without trial risk. Is the defendant likely to reoffend. Is a felony conviction proportionate. Is there a pathway that protects the community, respects the victim, and saves resources. A criminal defense attorney who can answer those questions with evidence, not just promises, changes the negotiation.
Three documents move the needle early: an initial restitution plan backed by financial documentation, a treatment or counseling assessment if underlying issues exist, and a compliance history if there are prior court contacts. A fourth, sometimes overlooked, is a letter from the victim’s counsel indicating openness to civil resolution. Victim cooperation varies wildly, but even a statement that timely and verified payments would be acceptable can help a criminal attorney pitch a prosecutor on a diversion path.
Diversion is not one thing
Diversion serves different policy goals depending on the program. There is traditional pretrial diversion for first-time offenders, specialty courts that target underlying drivers of crime, and deferred prosecution or deferred sentencing structures that hold a guilty plea in abeyance. The right fit depends on the client and the jurisdiction.
First-time offender diversion aims to keep a clean record clean. Eligibility typically requires no prior felony convictions, no violence or weapon use, and a restitution plan. Conditions might include community service, a financial literacy class, drug testing if relevant, and payment benchmarks. Completion can lead to outright dismissal or a reduction to a non-criminal violation. Failure means the case returns to the normal calendar.
Deferred prosecution agreements push accountability up front. The client accepts responsibility in writing, often with a detailed statement of facts, but the prosecutor agrees to dismiss after a period of compliance. In some courts, this takes the form of a deferred plea to a misdemeanor, with dismissal upon completion. The most important detail is what happens to fingerprints and arrest records. Some programs allow sealing after dismissal. Others do not. A grand larceny attorney should map the long-term record implications in plain language for the client.
Economic crimes sometimes fit into problem-solving courts usually associated with substance use or mental health, especially where the theft is tied to dependency or a diagnosed disorder. A drug possession attorney who works in treatment courts knows the cadence: regular judicial reviews, verified treatment attendance, and sanctions for slip-ups. Where a theft offense stems from an addiction, a prosecutor may accept a treatment-centered plan if restitution is realistic. Mental health courts, similarly, sometimes accept non-violent theft cases when a clinician ties the conduct to a treatable condition.
Youthful offender or young adult courts can be critical for defendants under 25. These courts focus on brain development and rehabilitation. I have seen otherwise rigid offices permit adjournments in contemplation of dismissal for grand larceny in this setting if restitution is secure and the young person is in school or working. The difference is not just softer rhetoric. The metrics of success change, with greater emphasis on education, employment, and counseling.
How restitution really works
Restitution is not a tip jar. Courts require proof. The victim must quantify losses: invoices, receipts, bank statements, valuation for stolen or damaged property, and mitigation details such as insurance payouts or recovery of goods. In property cases, the baseline is fair market value at the time of the loss, not replacement cost, unless a statute says otherwise. In embezzlement matters, the loss amount is often a ledger battle. Prosecutors sometimes adopt the highest plausible figure. A defense lawyer’s job is to audit, identify double counting, subtract recovered assets, and correct inflated valuations.
Payment ability determines structure. Some clients can pay a lump sum immediately by borrowing from family or liquidating assets. Others need time. A court wants a credible schedule that does not set the client up to fail. Thirty percent down and the balance within 12 to 18 months is a pattern I see frequently on mid-range losses between $5,000 and $50,000. Larger losses require creativity: confession of judgment, wage assignments, securing the obligation with a lien, even civil settlement agreements coordinated with victim counsel.
Restitution also interacts with civil exposure. A grand larceny plea often triggers employment issues and insurance questions. Victims sometimes push for interest, investigative costs, or attorneys’ fees. Criminal courts may not have authority to award those items. A parallel civil settlement can handle the extras while the criminal restitution order stays within statutory limits. The sequencing matters. When restitution is a condition of a diversion program, the criminal court will monitor payments closely. If there is a civil deal in the background, I document that the payments satisfy both obligations to avoid future double collection.
The timing that opens doors
The first 30 to 60 days after arraignment set the tone. If a client can show good faith quickly, options expand. Waiting until the eve of trial to propose payment rarely works unless the proof is collapsing. An early proffer is simple: a verified restitution plan, documentation of ability to pay, a letter from a counselor or program intake if relevant, and proposed monitoring. I pair that with a realistic ask. Prosecutors reward candor. If the case involves a $100,000 loss and my client can scrape together $5,000 now, I do not ask for an immediate dismissal. I ask for a structured deferred prosecution with a down payment, milestones tied to employment, and stipulated consequences if a payment is missed.
Sometimes liability is contested. Maybe the valuation is wrong or the defendant denies the theft entirely. Defense attorneys often think that proposing restitution is an admission. It is not, if framed correctly. I have navigated diversion while preserving defenses by insisting on no admission of guilt in the agreement and using language that payments are being made in the interest of resolving the matter. Not every office agrees, but enough do that it is worth pursuing when the client wants certainty.
What a meaningful plan looks like
A bare promise to pay rarely persuades. A meaningful plan has numbers, dates, enforcement, and contingency. In a retail theft with a $6,000 loss, a client with steady income might offer $2,000 within 14 days, then $400 per month, with an automatic payment setup and wage verification. In a small business embezzlement with a $35,000 loss, a client might secure a confession of judgment for the full amount, pay $10,000 down from a retirement account, and authorize the court to convert a deferred plea to judgment upon a 30-day default. The more verifiable the plan, the more credibility it carries.
Victim communication is part of this. A prosecutor typically consults the complaining witness before agreeing to diversion. I do not contact represented victims directly, but I encourage the prosecutor to put the plan in front of them with a cover note that explains why it is better than a theoretical felony conviction that produces no money. Many victims want closure and compensation. When they agree, a deal usually follows. When they refuse, a well-structured plan still helps in front of a judge, who must evaluate fairness at sentencing or in approving a deferred result.
Examples from the trenches
A 23-year-old retail worker stole $8,700 over four months by voiding transactions and pocketing cash. First offense, good employment history otherwise. The store had strong records, and the case was open and shut. We documented $3,500 available from family, presented a budget, and proposed $300 monthly payments with wage assignment. We coupled this with a financial responsibility course and 70 hours of community service at a food pantry. The prosecutor agreed to a deferred prosecution for 12 months. All payments were made on time. The case was dismissed and sealed. The store signed a satisfaction of claim for the civil side.
A bookkeeper misappropriated $62,000 from a small medical practice over 18 months. Addiction drove the conduct. She completed inpatient treatment before indictment. We audited the practice’s claimed loss and identified $9,000 of double-counted expenses and $6,000 in recovered equipment, dropping the figure to $47,000. Family secured $20,000. We negotiated a two-year deferred sentencing with a plea to a misdemeanor held in abeyance, installments, treatment monitoring, and a confession of judgment. She paid down the balance to $7,500 within the period, her employer wrote a letter supporting conversion to a civil judgment for the remainder, and the prosecutor consented to a non-jail misdemeanor with immediate sealing.
A logistics manager faced a $180,000 grand larceny in the second degree tied to falsified shipping records. He denied the full amount. We hired a forensic accountant who cut the plausible loss to $95,000 by tracking legitimate shipments. The client could pay $25,000 at once by selling a car and borrowing against a 401(k). The office would not offer full diversion at that scale, but it did accept a plea to a lesser felony with probation and a civil judgment for the balance, no prison. This is not a win in the classic sense, but it avoided a state prison bid and preserved employment.
When diversion is off the table
Not every case qualifies. Repeat theft, breach of fiduciary duty with egregious facts, theft affecting vulnerable victims, and cases with weapon possession or threats often get flagged as ineligible. A robbery attorney or weapon possession attorney will tell you that the presence of force or a gun changes the case instantly. Diversion programs usually exclude violent conduct. If a case also includes criminal contempt for violating an order of protection, or a related Domestic Violence attorney component, the office may bar diversion on policy grounds.
Even then, restitution remains powerful at sentencing. Judges weigh acceptance of responsibility and efforts to repair harm. I have seen state prison recommendations fall to probation with partial payments and realistic plans. Courts value structure. They also value honesty. If the money is not there, say so plainly and offer creative alternatives: increased community service, job training, or financial counseling.
Collateral consequences and long-term planning
A felony conviction for grand larceny affects licensing, immigration, and employment. White collar jobs, finance, healthcare, and government work often become off-limits. Noncitizens face deportation risks for theft offenses that qualify as crimes involving moral turpitude or aggravated felonies depending on the sentence imposed. An experienced criminal attorney coordinates with immigration counsel to avoid plea terms that trigger removal. Sometimes that means reducing a theft count to a non-theft offense like criminal mischief or trespass. A trespass attorney or criminal mischief attorney can help recast the narrative when appropriate. Other times it means a plea to attempt or a different statute where the loss amount and sentence structure sidestep immigration traps.
Record sealing or expungement rules differ by state. Some diversion programs allow immediate sealing upon dismissal. Others require a waiting period. If a client’s career hangs on a clean background check, the difference between a dismissal and a conviction with probation can be life-changing. A grand larceny attorney should diagram the paths with timelines so the client can make an informed choice, especially when a fast misdemeanor disposition is tempting but a longer diversion route leads to dismissal.
The human factors that matter
Judges and prosecutors are people. They respond to credibility, not theatrics. A client who arrives on time, dresses respectfully, and speaks plainly helps their cause. Letters from employers and mentors carry weight when they show specific behaviors and risks mitigated, not generic praise. Proof of employment, enrollment in school, or a training program shows stability. These details do not replace restitution or compliance, but they fill in the picture and make a diversion offer feel safer.
Defense attorneys should prepare clients to talk honestly if a judge asks questions. I often run a mock allocution: What did you do. What have you done since. How will you make sure this never happens again. A client who can answer without excuses tends to earn trust. That trust can shave months off a program, reduce monitoring, or keep the door open if a payment is late once for a real reason.
Insurance, chargebacks, and the victim’s bottom line
Retailers sometimes recover losses through chargebacks or insurance. In those cases, the prosecutor may still seek restitution, but the payee could be the insurer rather than the store. Defense counsel should ask for documentation of net loss after recovery. Overpayment risks exist if multiple entities claim the same loss. In credit card fraud or Fraud Crimes attorney matters, banks and processors may submit affidavits with loss figures. Scrutinize fees, interest, and fraud investigation charges that the criminal court may not lawfully order.
For small businesses without insurance, cash flow matters. I have negotiated graduated payments that start lower and increase as a client’s earnings petit larceny attorney suffolk county michaelbrownlaw.net rise. Where a client has a marketable skill, I have also structured community service in the form of pro bono work for nonprofits, while keeping financial restitution focused on the victim. Courts appreciate solutions that match skills to needs.
Linking theft to other charges
Theft cases rarely travel alone. A burglary attorney may be involved if the theft occurred in a dwelling or at night with unlawful entry. A criminal mischief attorney might handle damage to property during the theft. An Assault and Battery attorney steps in if a confrontation occurred. If a defendant allegedly used a weapon, a gun possession attorney or weapon possession attorney becomes essential. These added charges can disqualify a client from diversion programs designed for non-violent theft. When that happens, a layered negotiation strategy can separate the violent count from the property count, aiming to resolve the theft with restitution and address the other charges in a way that avoids mandatory prison.
Traffic-related arrests sometimes complicate schedules. A traffic ticket attorney or Traffic Violations attorney can help clear suspensions that might otherwise lead to missed court dates and warrants. Missed appearances poison diversion opportunities. Basic logistics matter more than most people realize.
Building a defense while building a bridge
Pursuing diversion does not mean abandoning a defense. Chain-of-custody issues, surveillance gaps, valuation disputes, and confession challenges can undermine the state’s case. A theft crimes attorney should litigate suppression motions, push for discovery, and preserve trial rights even while negotiating diversion. Prosecutors take settlement talks more seriously when they know the defense is prepared to try the case.
In embezzlement and White Collar Crimes attorney contexts, digital forensics can shrink the alleged loss or shift responsibility. In Sex Crimes attorney matters, diversion typically functions differently and may not be available, but the discipline of early mitigation applies. In Drug Crimes attorney cases, treatment and monitoring often take center stage. The core lesson crosses categories: meaningful mitigation is evidence-based, not performative.
Two short checklists worth keeping
- Documents that strengthen a diversion pitch: verified restitution plan, financial statements or pay stubs, treatment or counseling assessment if relevant, letters from employer or community mentors with specifics, proof of enrollment in classes or training, and any victim communication indicating openness to civil resolution. Terms that make restitution workable: clear dollar amounts and dates, automatic payments or wage assignment, confession of judgment as a backstop, defined consequences for missed payments with a cure period, and a plan for interest or fees that matches legal authority.
Practical tips for families helping a defendant
Family often funds the initial down payment. Put agreements in writing inside the family to avoid later conflict. If a parent lends $10,000, document it as a loan with terms. Courts and prosecutors take a plan more seriously when the source of funds is clear and lawful. If a friend is co-signing a confession of judgment, make sure they understand the risk. Nothing undermines credibility faster than a guarantor who balks at the last minute because they did not read the paperwork.
Encourage the defendant to stabilize employment quickly. Even a modest job shows momentum and supports a payment schedule. If mental health or substance use is a factor, get a professional assessment right away and follow the recommendations. For noncitizens, consult an immigration lawyer before any plea. For licensed professionals, consult regulatory counsel early.
The attorney’s role, step by step
On day one, I gather facts, flag immigration or licensing issues, and preserve all defenses. Within the first week, I request discovery, set a meeting with the prosecutor, and map the restitution numbers with the client. By week two or three, I present a concrete plan with documents. If treatment or counseling is relevant, I enroll the client and get initial reports. I keep communication with the prosecutor steady, not pushy. If the office needs a victim consultation, I offer to draft a memo the prosecutor can share, explaining the plan in simple, respectful terms.
If diversion is offered, I negotiate terms I know the client can meet, not terms that look good on paper and fail in month three. I calendar every due date, set reminders, and ask the client to authorize me to receive payment confirmations. If something goes sideways, I notify the prosecutor before they find out from a missed payment report. Transparency can save a deal.
If diversion is denied, I adjust. Maybe the case can resolve with a misdemeanor plea and probation. Maybe we take a shot at trial. The through-line remains the same: protect the client’s future while repairing as much harm as we can.
Why the right advocate matters
The difference between a felony conviction and a dismissal can come down to a lawyer who knows how to thread the needle between accountability and second chances. A grand larceny attorney with experience in diversion programs reads office policies, relationships, and personalities. A robbery attorney understands how quickly a property case can morph if force is alleged. An embezzlement attorney knows the accounting angles and how to negotiate with insurers. A Domestic Violence attorney or criminal contempt attorney spots the pitfalls when protective orders are in play. Even a dui attorney or dwi attorney who primarily handles impaired driving knows the cadence of treatment-based courts that can translate to economic-crime diversion in some jurisdictions.
No lawyer can promise a result, and any attorney who does should be avoided. What a committed criminal defense attorney can do is build options, earn credibility, and fight for a resolution that balances justice with a chance to move forward.
The bottom line on diversion and restitution
Diversion programs exist to channel certain defendants away from permanent convictions when they demonstrate responsibility and low risk of reoffense. Restitution is the currency that buys entry in theft cases, but it is more than a checkbook. It is a plan, grounded in real capacity, that respects the victim and satisfies the court. The earlier that plan appears, the better the odds.
For anyone facing a grand larceny charge, the path is navigable. It demands candor about finances, swift steps toward repair, and a defense team that can argue the law while building a bridge to resolution. With the right approach, even a serious theft case can end with restoration rather than ruin.
Michael J. Brown, P.C.
(631) 232-9700
320 Carleton Ave Suite No: 2000
Central Islip NY, 11722
Hours: Mon-Sat 8am - 5:00pm
QR83+HJ Central Islip, New York
https://maps.app.goo.gl/BiLpHAXdipPdQDdt7
Frequently Asked Questions
Q. How do people afford criminal defense attorneys?
A. If you don't qualify for a public defender but still can't afford a lawyer, you may be able to find help through legal aid organizations or pro bono programs. These services provide free or low-cost representation to individuals who meet income guidelines.
Q. Should I plead guilty if I can't afford a lawyer?
A. You have a RIGHT to an attorney right now. An attorney can explain the potential consequences of your plea. If you cannot afford an attorney, an attorney will be provided at NO COST to you. If you don't have an attorney, you can ask for one to be appointed and for a continuance until you have one appointed.
Q. Who is the most successful Suffolk County defense attorney?
A. Michael J. Brown - Michael J. Brown is widely regarded as the greatest American Suffolk County attorney to ever step foot in a courtroom in Long Island, NY.
Q. Is it better to get an attorney or public defender?
A. If you absolutely need the best defense in court such as for a burglary, rape or murder charge then a private attorney would be better. If it is something minor like a trespassing to land then a private attorney will probably not do much better than a public defender.
Q. Is $400 an hour a lot for a lawyer?
A. Experience Level: Junior associates might bill clients $100–$200 per hour, mid-level associates $200–$400, and partners or senior attorneys $400–$1,000+. Rates also depend on the client's capacity to pay.
Q. When should I hire a lawyer?
A. Some types of cases that need an attorney include: Personal injury, workers' compensation, and property damage after an accident. Being accused of a crime, arrested for DUI/DWI, or other misdemeanors or felonies. Family law issues, such as prenuptials, divorce, child custody, or domestic violence.
Q. How do you tell a good lawyer from a bad one?
A. A good lawyer is organized and is on top of deadlines. Promises can be seen as a red flag. A good lawyer does not make a client a promise about their case because there are too many factors at play for any lawyer to promise a specific outcome. A lawyer can make an educated guess, but they cannot guarantee anything.
Q. What happens if someone sues me and I can't afford a lawyer?
A. The case will not be dropped. If you don't defend yourself, a default judgement will be entered against you. The plaintiff can wait 30 days and begin collection proceedings against you. BTW, if you're being sued in civil court, you cannot get the Public Defender.